Pro Tip: Ugly Flies Catch Fish Too!

Written by: John McKinnie, Lone Mountain Ranch

The Madison River trout didn’t seem to mind that Elliot’s pattern wasn’t perfect.
Photo by John McKinnie

I have a problem to admit: I have become a fly snob! The more time I spend fly fishing, the more concerned I have become with the aesthetic appeal of fly patterns. I believe that I developed this desire for perfect patterns for several reasons. First, since I have been fishing for trout as long as I can remember, my fish sense has developed to a very advanced stage where I know that trout prefer the flies with flawless hackle and wing construction. Next, I have spent tons of hours looking at pictures of beautifully manicured fly patterns in catalogs when preparing fly orders for our shop. Finally, when visiting all the local fly shops around Southwest Montana, all you see are thousands of bins filled with perfect imitations of Prince Nymphs, Elk Hair Caddis, and Woolly Buggers.

The Mega Prince is a great early-season stonefly imitation.
Photo via Caddis Fly Shop

I was reminded yesterday that trout don’t really care what your fly looks like as long as it looks buggy. On my maiden float trip on the Madison River for 2015, I fished with two of our wrangler/fishing guides from the ranch, Elliot and Craig. Elliot has recently started learning the art of fly tying. Anyone who has spent time behind the vise knows that it can be frustrating, and in the beginning it is hard to get your patterns to look anywhere close to what you intended. When I was starting out, I threw away plenty of flies that I had tied just because I thought they were ugly and didn’t look anything like the Prince Nymph in the book or the flies that I saw in the bins at the shops. Elliot has the type of optimistic personality where he thinks that all his flies look good and will catch fish despite how deformed, or funky, the final product looks.

Elliot is all smiles after landing his first rainbow on a fly he tied.
Photo by John McKinnie

The Mega Prince is a great pattern on the Madison any time of year, but is most effective in the winter and spring months. I suggested this to Elliot as we geared up to start the day, and he mentioned that he’d just tied a Mega Prince the night before. (You can find a video on tying this pattern at the bottom of the post.) I examined his “attempt” at the Mega Prince, and it was far from the pattern I had just purchased at the shop in Ennis. Elliot’s fly had wings going in all directions, bright thread and peacock herl, and an extremely thin profile which made the nymph look like it had missed a few meals.

Craig got into the action, as well.
Photo by John McKinnie

I smugly remarked to Elliot, “It might work; might as well give it a try.” After just a few casts, Elliot had hooked into a beautiful spring rainbow, and he was thrilled! Not only did he land an awesome fish, but he caught it on a fly that he tied, as well.

Throughout the day, Elliot’s Mega Prince continued to fool plenty of healthy Madison River trout. Near the take-out, Elliot snagged a rock and he lost his pattern to the fishing gods. He had hoped to pin that Mega Prince on the bill of his hat to display proudly, but I think it was more fitting to lose it to the river. Elliot can now construct another unique pattern that I am sure will fool a fish or two!

Elliot’s Mega Prince was the clear winner of the day.
Photo by John McKinnie

John McKinnie is the Fly-Fishing Manager at Lone Mountain Ranch in Big Sky, Montana.

14 thoughts on “Pro Tip: Ugly Flies Catch Fish Too!”

  1. It’s interesting how some folks migrate towards more and more complex flies while others (and I see myself very much in this camp) go just the opposite direction – moving away from the maddening desire to find the perfect fly and instead seek simplicity in patterns.

    1. I’ve always wondered just how much detail a trout can see as a nymph blows by it at Mach speed. I primarily fish small NC free stones, and I think I fuss too much about my flies. I’ve been tying about a year, and my worst flies catch fish if I fish them like I expect them to catch fish.

  2. After an almost 10 year hiatus i have returned to the fly bench and have started to teach my 11 year old to tie and fish. While cleaning out and organizing fly boxes i noticed how ugly a lot of my old flies were compared to what i am tying now. Then i remembered ( about to brag ) that the last 4 years i fished heavy , i never once went a day getting skunked. Point is, I guess the uglies fished just fine. But I still prefer them pretty.

  3. I bought my first bunch of flies in Herman’s sporting goods in Times Square back in the day. I believe that they were tied by a company called True Life Flies, they were GR Hares Ears nymphs and they woefully not proportioned well, certainly not like Abercrombie’s Nymphs in their nice display cases. I paid 40 cents apiece for them and damn if they didn’t catch fish!!! And yes I did try the the one’s at the Fifth Ave store, those were 75 cents and not great fish catchers, but they were certainly well tied and proportionately correct.

  4. Growing up, my Dad would give me a handful of brand new, perfectly tied Orvis or LL Bean Royal Wulff’s before each outing – this was the 70’s. At the end of the day, he always collected the remaining flies, showing particular interest in those I had used. Took me a long time to piece together what was happening – I was “breaking them” so they looked more natural. When I finally asked him to confirm my suspicions, he admitted the more ratty the fly became, the more fish it caught.

    Hail the ugly fly!

  5. Who are we trying to catch with the perfectly tied fly, the fish or the fishermen? I think the latter!!

  6. Pingback: Tippets: Long Leaders, Invasive Landmarks, Buggy Flies | MidCurrent
  7. Pingback: Ugly Flies Catch Fish Too! | mckinnieflyfishingmontanadotnet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *