Victory at Last in the Fight Against Pebble Mine!

The fight to save the world’s last great wild-salmon run has been spearheaded by anglers and hunters.
Photo by Cory Luoma, Fly Out Media

Today, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers announced its decision to deny a permit for the proposed Pebble Mine in the Bristol Bay region of Alaska, ending a years-long battle to protect a pristine wilderness and ecosystem—as well as 14,000 American jobs and fishing industries worth $1.5 billion annually. The decision effectively stops the project in its tracks and represents a tremendous victory for the coalition of anglers, hunters, indigenous peoples, commercial fishermen, and environmentalists who have been fighting to protect the world’s last great wild-salmon run and the countless populations of animals, fish, and birds that depend on it. It’s time to pop the corks on a few bottle of Champaign to savor this moment, which represents a win for everyone who values untouched wilderness

“Thank you to all who came together and made their voices heard to keep one of the world’s great watersheds pristine. Today, Bristol Bay, AK is one step closer to being a protected American treasure that sustains local communities and industries and that outdoor enthusiasts can enjoy and experience for generations to come.” Orvis President Simon Perkins

This glorious expanse of wilderness is no place for an industrial-scale mining operation.
Photo by Pat Clayton, Fish Eye Guy Photography

Teamwork Pays Off

For more than a decade, Orvis has teamed with Trout Unlimited and many other groups to oppose the proposed open-pit mine situated at the headwaters of an incredible watershed that supports huge annual runs of sockeye salmon. In 2020, more than 52 million sockeyes entered the system to spawn, supporting both commercial and recreational fishing industries, as well as a traditional way of life for the area’s indigenous peoples. Through matching-grant campaigns, we teamed with our customers to raise money to support anti-Pebble activities; we used our catalogs, stores, and social-media accounts to raise awareness; we took out full-page ads in major newspapers; we lobbied lawmakers in Washington, DC; and we did whatever else we could to help bring others into the fight. The next big goal will be to achieve permanent protection, such as designation as a Wilderness Area.

Thank You

There is no way that we could have sustained this effort or achieved this victory without the continued support of Orvis customers, who gave their money, their time, and their voices to the cause. Our matching-grants program raised $77,000 for Pebble last year alone; Orvis customers have signed petitions and sent emails, texts, and letters to lawmakers; and they have stood with us even when it seemed as though the fight was lost. The Orvis commitment to what we love is a foundation of our brand, which is why the company dedicates 5% of pre-tax profits to conservation efforts. We thank you for sharing our values and our desire to protect nature and for your willingness to use your voices when called upon. As our CEO Perk Perkins says, ““If we are going to benefit from our natural resources, we must be willing to take action to protect them.”

As we celebrate this victory for the environment and for our children’s futures, it’s important to note that this may not be the end of the story, however. The Canadian mining company behind the Pebble Project could regroup and start the permitting process over again–at which point we shall heed King Henry’s famous call: “Once more unto the breach, dear friends, once more.”

As always, we will continue to keep you updated on the Pebble Mine story, and if this monster rears its ugly head again, we will be ready.

Click here to read the full story in the New York Times.

Click Here to Visit the Orvis Commitment Pages

A pristine Bristol Bay watershed will provide great fly fishing for generations to come.
Photo by Cory Luoma, Fly Out Media

***

Here’s the text of the statement from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers:

Today, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers – Alaska District issued a record of decision that denies the Pebble Limited Partnership’s permit application to develop a copper-molybdenum-gold mine in southwest Alaska under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act and Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act.

This decision on the proposed Pebble Project culminates a review process that lasted nearly three years and involved the development of an environmental impact statement. That assessment included an in-depth analysis of project alternatives along with an examination of supplemental technical information provided by cooperating agencies and the public. In its record of decision, USACE determined that the applicant’s plan for the discharge of fill material does not comply with Clean Water Act guidelines and concluded that the proposed project is contrary to the public interest.

This action is based on all available facts and complies with existing laws and regulations. It reflects a regulatory process that is fair, flexible and balanced. USACE is committed to maintaining and restoring the nation’s aquatic resources, while allowing reasonable development.

We strived for transparency, collaboration, accuracy and expediency throughout the decision-making process. We truly value and appreciate the contributions of everyone who engaged in this endeavor. Now, I’m proud to say that we delivered on our promise to conduct a thorough review and make a timely permit decision.

52 thoughts on “Victory at Last in the Fight Against Pebble Mine!”

    1. Thank god fuck that orange piece of shit in the White House he’s trying to ruin everything thankfully we have people who care

      1. You need to check your facts, quit listening to cnn and clean up your filthy mouth. You can always tell a persons intellect by their vocabulary.

        1. And who they believe for real news, Frank!

          Yeah You! Perhaps you should check your facts. I mean real ones. Unlike the babble spouted on FOX.

          Often, people with excellent vocabulary, sadly, have no intellect to speak of aswell.
          Cheers Frank

  1. The long S-U-S-T-A-I-N-E-D fight paid off. Huge thanks to all those who continued to support the members of the collaboration that convinced the decision makers of this economic folly and environmental insanity.

  2. Wonderful news, never should have taken this long. Congratulations to all who worked hard in the fight against this terrible project.

  3. A round of applause, congratulations, and gratitude to all those people and organizations who have had the courage and persistence to bring this day about.

    Now onto the hard work it will take to preserve this watershed in perpetuity.

    1. It’s great that we recognize that this administration has been protecting our environment. (Not intended as sarcasm but truth)

      1. I heartily second this! Our great President Trump has been our victor all the while. Protecting not only our environment but also us, our country, our rights, our liberties, economy, jobs, with genuine love and attention for the needs of people of all race, our national security against foes, and personal choices in medical care. Protecting with sanity, genuine love, careful and reasoned guidance, and with humility and humble spirit toward his Maker. No force, no spies: freedom.

  4. Thank you Orvis for highlighting the Pebble plan to the world of descent humanity and for having the tenacity to hang on to the ‘victorious’ outcome. However as you so rightly point out the the job is not yet watertight i.e. Wilderness status must be pursued.

  5. Thank you for making me aware of this situation. I am so happy to hear that the mine permit has been denied. Thank you for leading this fight.

    1. Aw shucks!

      Some things during the present regime are “Unpardonable” (sarcasm intended), namely this win for the 99% of us who value the outdoors and the greater good.

      Godspeed and thanks.

  6. Congratulations on all your cooperative hard work for such an important cause! This victory restores faith and hope for our natural environment. Well Done!

  7. Thank you Army Corps of Engineers. Trump had nothing to do with it. He’s never heard of Bristol Bay.

    1. I beg your pardon! I received a letter from the Office of the President, thanking me for my effort in trying to thwart this plan by the Pebble Mine Partnership. You are so “dumbed down” by hatred to perceive truth and to rightfully accord any act that shows heartfelt love of America and its people to the President. My praise, thanks, and gratitude to all who involved themselves in defeat of the selfish interests of those who would rob, plunder and desecrate at the altar of the almighty dollar.

    1. Unfortunately, there will always be haters. Sad where the world is going.
      I give a to Trump! And all involved.

  8. Like always, Biden will take the credit if you explain it slowly to him, and like always, his supporters will believe it, if you don’t get too much into the real facts.

  9. I’d give more credit for this victory over polluters to the native peoples of the region than anyone in this scandalous administration. Trump’s EPA’s picks: grifter Scott Pruitt, Andrew Wheeler a coal lobbyist. Trump’s Interior Secretary pick: Ryan Zinke, another grifter who had to resign. “Only the best people.”

    1. “Scandulous administration” you say, Mr. Leavitt? Your prejudiced hostility and the unreasoned distortion of your judgment and belief system have shut your mind and heart. No longer can you perceive truth, and you have little capacity left for rational thinking.

      1. To D. T. Vail, Your words “the selfish interests of those who would rob, plunder, and desecrate at the altar of the almighty dollar.”, perfectly describes this administration and the Trump family.

  10. Hurrah, there are still those who actually care about the environment and world their children will actually be inheriting . Thank you to everyone

  11. I had the privilege to be stationed At King Salmon courtesy of the US Air Force from September 1993 to September 1994. The Bristol Bay Area is a magnificent place, and I am happy to see the Pebble Mine has been denied.

  12. One can only rejoice that nature can prevail in this gorgeous setting. We know that the current president didn’t want it to go this way, and I suppose we must be grateful that a son is a hunter/fisherman . Yay to the Corps!.

  13. Thanks to Orvis, TU and others for keeping up the fight to deny this permit! Some things are far more important than “
    Economic development “ at the expense of our natural resources and we need to insure this wonderful resource stays in place for future generations.

  14. Perk Perkins involvement in Pebble mine fight was immeasurable. Let’s applaud him for his work and doggidnance.

  15. I am thrilled that this ecosystem was saved from destruction . We do not want to become a polluted mess like China, India and parts of Russia. But! the devil is in the details and this will leave us dependent on those countries for strategic materials for defense and industry. I do not know the answer. Dam if you do, dam if you don’t. I am relieved that sane minds prevailed because this is one of the most important social issues of our time.

  16. What an accomplishment by President Trump and all The People involved to get this done in Our Last Frontier of the United States!!!

  17. Hmmmmmmmm. All this heat over Trump – not sure why he denied it as that is contrary to his reckless approach to the environment. But importantly, he did and the world is a better place and this wonderful natural resource will remain pristine for a long time – as long as we remain vigilant – support TU and all the other organizations who work to protect cold water fisheries. So, thank you President Trump for listening to Tucker Carlson when he asked you to step back from this pending disaster. Again, Tucker Carlson can successfully be on the wrong side of much but credit to him for being on the right side of this one; for being someone that President Trump trusts and for taking a very public stand advocating for this fishery. So, let’s all just step back from all the partisan acrimony and count our blessings that this project has been killed for the time being. Now President Elect Joe Biden work with Congress to make this permanent and put this out of reach of developers for all of time.

    Thank you Orvis, TU, Tucker, Prez and most importantly, the thousands of American and International friends of the environment who donated their time and funds to stopping Pebble. This victory does not end the struggle to save our wildernesses and our planet. On to the next battle!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *